mai-rice.comJapanese rice, fermentation, pantry, no-waste
Substitute Guide

No Amazake? Here Are the Closest Alternatives for Drinks and Cooking

First, which amazake are you substituting? There are two types — and they require different substitutes. Koji amazake is a thick, sweet, non-alcoholic rice drink made by fermenting cooked rice with koji mold at 55–60°C. Sake kasu amazake is a thinner, mildly alcoholic drink made from sake lees dissolved in hot water. Both are called 'amazake' in Japan, but they taste different, behave differently in recipes, and need different alternatives. This guide covers substitutes for each type across three applications: drinking, cooking, and marinades.

For what amazake is → What Is Amazake. For recipe ideas → How to Use Amazake. For making it from scratch → How to Make Amazake. This page covers alternatives only.

Updated

WHICH ARE YOU REPLACING?

  • As a drink: Horchata (closest grain-based sweet drink) or banana-oat smoothie
  • As a sweetener in cooking: Maple syrup at 75% quantity
  • In marinades: Mirin + water at 1:1 ratio
  • In baking: Applesauce + a splash of sake

The Two Types of Amazake (and Why It Matters)

Before choosing a substitute, you need to know which amazake your recipe calls for. The two types are fundamentally different products that share a name.

Koji Amazake (Non-Alcoholic)

Made by incubating cooked rice with koji (Aspergillus oryzae mold) at 55–60°C for 8–12 hours. The koji’s amylase enzymes convert the rice starch into glucose and maltose, producing a thick, sweet, porridge-like drink with zero alcohol. The sweetness is entirely from converted rice sugars — no added sweetener. Koji amazake contains about 18 g of sugar per 100 ml (compared to orange juice at 10 g and Coca-Cola at 11 g). It is naturally rich in B vitamins and amino acids from the koji fermentation.

Sake Kasu Amazake (Mildly Alcoholic)

Made by dissolving sake kasu (the solid lees remaining after sake is pressed) in hot water, typically with added sugar. It contains 1–2% alcohol from the residual alcohol in the lees. Sake kasu amazake has a thinner body than koji amazake, with a more complex flavor — yeasty, fruity, slightly boozy — inherited from the sake fermentation. It is the type traditionally served at shrines during New Year festivals and at Hinamatsuri (Girls’ Day) celebrations.

Bottom line: If your recipe calls for amazake as a sweetener (marinades, baking, smoothies), it almost certainly means koji amazake. If it is a warm winter drink recipe, it could be either type — check for sake kasu in the ingredients.

For the full explanation, see What is amazake.

For Drinking: Horchata or Banana-Oat Smoothie

Horchata

Mexican horchata is the closest widely available drink to amazake in concept and experience: both are grain-based (rice), naturally sweet, creamy, and served either warm or cold. Horchata is made by soaking rice and cinnamon in water, blending, straining, and sweetening. The texture is thinner than koji amazake but shares the same starchy, milky mouthfeel.

Adjustment for closer match: Make horchata with less cinnamon (or none) and less sugar than typical recipes — amazake’s flavor is subtler and less spiced. Standard horchata: 1 cup rice soaked 4 hours, blended with 4 cups water and a cinnamon stick, strained, sweetened with 3 tablespoons sugar. For amazake approximation: omit the cinnamon, reduce sugar to 1 tablespoon, and add 1 tablespoon of sake for a faint fermented note.

Banana-Oat Smoothie

For a quick, single-serving alternative: blend 1 ripe banana, 1/4 cup rolled oats, 1 cup water or milk, and 1 teaspoon honey. The banana provides natural sweetness and body, the oats add a grain-like creaminess, and the result is thick, smooth, and satisfying in the same way that warm amazake is. This obviously does not taste like amazake — but it fills the same role as a sweet, nourishing, grain-based drink.

For sake kasu amazake (the alcoholic type): Add 1 tablespoon of sake to either the horchata or the smoothie. This provides the mild alcohol warmth and fermented complexity of the sake lees version.

For Cooking (As a Sweetener): Maple Syrup at 75%

Amazake functions as a gentle liquid sweetener in Japanese cooking — it sweetens sauces, glazes, and dressings without the intensity of sugar. Its sweetness is roughly 30–40% of sugar’s intensity by volume, meaning recipes using amazake produce subtly sweet results.

Maple syrup is the best liquid sweetener substitute. Use 75% of the amazake volume — if a recipe calls for 4 tablespoons amazake, use 3 tablespoons maple syrup. Maple syrup is sweeter than amazake (67% sugar vs. 18%), so reducing the quantity compensates. The flavor profiles are different (maple is tree-sap caramel, amazake is rice-grain delicate) but both add a gentle, rounded sweetness.

Alternative: Mirin can substitute in savory cooking applications. Use the same volume as amazake but be aware that mirin adds 14% alcohol (which mostly cooks off) and is saltier than amazake. Mirin works particularly well in teriyaki glazes, simmered dishes, and dipping sauces where amazake’s sweetness is part of a larger flavor system.

For more on mirin as a sweetener, see What is mirin.

For Marinades: Mirin + Water (1:1)

Amazake marinades work through three mechanisms: (1) the sugars promote Maillard browning, producing an attractive golden crust on grilled or roasted proteins; (2) the koji enzymes gently break down protein fibers, tenderizing meat and fish; (3) the mild sweetness balances salt from soy sauce or miso in the marinade.

Best substitute: Mix mirin and water at a 1:1 ratio. Use 2 tablespoons of this mixture for every 3 tablespoons of amazake in the recipe. The mirin provides rice-derived sweetness and fermented character; the water dilutes it to amazake’s milder sweetness level. The alcohol in mirin (14%) also acts as a penetration agent, carrying flavor deeper into the protein.

What you lose: The tenderizing enzyme activity. Amazake’s koji enzymes (proteases) actively break down protein — mirin does not have this effect. To partially compensate, marinate for 30–60 minutes longer than the recipe specifies. Alternatively, add a tablespoon of grated fresh ginger to the marinade — ginger contains the protease zingibain, which provides some tenderizing action.

Marinating times with the substitute: Fish fillets: 45–90 minutes (vs. 30–60 with amazake). Chicken thighs: 3–6 hours (vs. 2–4). Pork loin: 6–12 hours (vs. 4–8). Do not exceed these times with fish — the acid in mirin can over-cure the surface, making it mushy.

For Baking: Applesauce + Sake

In baking, amazake provides moisture, natural sweetness, and a subtle fermented complexity. The best substitute is unsweetened applesauce, which matches amazake’s moisture content and body, plus a small amount of sake for the fermented note.

Ratio: 3/4 cup unsweetened applesauce + 1 tablespoon sake (or mirin) for every 1 cup of amazake called for in the recipe. Reduce other liquids by 2 tablespoons to account for the slightly thicker consistency of applesauce.

Best for: Muffins, pancakes, quick breads, and any batter where amazake contributes moisture and mild sweetness. For cookies, the additional moisture from applesauce may make the dough too wet — increase flour by 1–2 tablespoons to compensate.

Alternative: Mashed banana (1/2 banana per 1/2 cup amazake) works in recipes where banana flavor is compatible. It adds more natural sweetness than applesauce, so you may want to reduce any added sugar slightly.

Why Amazake Has No Perfect Substitute

Amazake’s uniqueness comes from koji — the Aspergillus oryzae mold that produces the enzymes converting rice starch to sugar. This enzymatic process creates a specific sugar profile (primarily glucose and maltose) that tastes different from sucrose (table sugar), fructose (fruit sugar), or the sugar combinations in honey or maple syrup. Koji also produces amino acids and B vitamins during fermentation, contributing a subtle savory depth beneath the sweetness.

No other widely available food product combines this exact sugar profile, thick rice body, and fermented complexity. The substitutes in this guide approximate one or two of these qualities per application, but none replicate all three.

If you use amazake regularly, consider making it at home — it requires only rice, koji, and a rice cooker held at 55–60°C for 8–12 hours. For the step-by-step process, see How to make amazake. For recipe ideas beyond substitution, see How to use amazake.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does amazake taste like?
Koji amazake (the non-alcoholic type) tastes like sweet rice porridge — thick, creamy, and gently sweet with a subtle grain-like nuttiness and a faint koji fragrance (slightly floral, almost mushroom-like). The sweetness comes entirely from enzyme-converted rice sugars, not added sweetener, so it tastes 'natural sweet' rather than sugary. Sake kasu amazake (made from sake lees) is thinner, slightly boozy (1–2% alcohol), and has a more complex, fermented flavor with yeasty and fruity notes. Neither type is cloyingly sweet — amazake is roughly 18% sugar compared to honey at 80% or maple syrup at 67%.
Is amazake alcoholic?
It depends on the type. Koji amazake (kome koji amazake) is made by fermenting cooked rice with koji mold at 55–60°C for 8–12 hours. This temperature activates amylase enzymes that convert starch to sugar but is too high for alcohol-producing yeast to survive. Koji amazake contains 0.0% alcohol and is safe for children and pregnant women. Sake kasu amazake is made by dissolving sake lees (the solid byproduct of sake pressing) in hot water with sugar. It contains 1–2% alcohol from the residual alcohol in the lees. Always check the label — both types are sold under the name 'amazake' in Japanese stores.
Can I use amazake substitute in a marinade?
Yes. Amazake is used as a marinade for fish and meat because its sugars promote browning (Maillard reaction) while its enzymes gently tenderize protein. The best substitute for marinades is mirin diluted with water at a 1:1 ratio — mirin provides similar rice-derived sweetness and fermented depth. Use 2 tablespoons of diluted mirin for every 3 tablespoons of amazake called for in the recipe. The tenderizing effect will be slightly less because mirin lacks amazake's active enzymes, but the flavor profile and browning will be close. Marinate fish for 30–60 minutes, chicken for 2–4 hours.
Can I substitute amazake in baking?
Yes, with adjustments. Amazake functions as both a liquid sweetener and a moisture source in baking. The best substitute is unsweetened applesauce plus a small splash of sake or mirin: use 3/4 cup applesauce + 1 tablespoon sake for every 1 cup of amazake. The applesauce provides moisture, body, and natural sweetness; the sake adds a subtle fermented note. Reduce other liquids in the recipe by about 2 tablespoons since applesauce is thicker than amazake. This works well in muffins, pancakes, and quick breads. For cookies, the higher moisture may affect texture — reduce liquid further or increase flour by 1–2 tablespoons.
Where can I buy amazake?
In Japan, amazake is sold at every convenience store and supermarket, especially during winter. Outside Japan, look in the refrigerated section of Japanese grocery stores (Mitsuwa, Nijiya, Marukai) — Marukome and Morinaga are common brands. Shelf-stable amazake in cans or pouches is available at some Asian grocery stores and online. In natural food stores, you may find amazake from US-based producers like Grainaissance or Rhapsody (these tend to be thinner and less sweet than Japanese brands). A 1-liter carton costs roughly $6–10. If you cannot find it locally, making koji amazake at home is straightforward with a rice cooker.
How do I make amazake at home?
Cook 1 cup of Japanese short-grain rice with extra water (1.5 cups instead of the usual 1.2) to produce a soft, porridge-like consistency. Cool to 60°C (140°F) — this is critical, as temperatures above 65°C kill the koji enzymes. Stir in 200 g of rice koji (available at Japanese grocery stores or online). Transfer to a container, cover loosely, and hold at 55–60°C for 8–12 hours. A rice cooker on 'keep warm' mode (with the lid propped open slightly with a chopstick to prevent overheating) works well. After 8 hours, the rice will be very sweet and the mixture will have thinned. Blend smooth, refrigerate, and consume within 5–7 days.
What is the nutritional value of amazake?
Koji amazake contains roughly 81 calories per 100 ml, with 18 g of carbohydrates (almost all simple sugars from the koji enzyme conversion), 1.7 g of protein, and 0.2 g of fat. It is naturally rich in B vitamins (B1, B2, B6) produced by the koji fermentation — historically called 'drinkable IV drip' in Japan for its restorative properties during summer heat and illness recovery. It provides glucose, amino acids, and oligosaccharides (prebiotic fiber). Compared to other sweeteners: amazake has about 80 calories per 100 ml vs. honey at 300 calories per 100 ml, making it a lower-calorie sweetening option with additional nutritional benefits.
Can I freeze amazake?
Yes. Amazake freezes well for up to 3 months in airtight containers or freezer bags. Leave 2 cm of headspace for expansion. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight or in a bowl of warm water for 30 minutes. The texture may separate slightly after thawing — stir or blend briefly to re-emulsify. For cooking applications, frozen amazake can be added directly to hot liquids or marinades without thawing first. Some people freeze amazake in ice cube trays (each cube is roughly 2 tablespoons) for convenient portioning in recipes. Home-made amazake benefits from freezing because it stops the fermentation, preserving the sweetness level at the point you preferred.